Assignment 06 — Getting Used to the Numbers

This assignment is about numbers. The derivations are all in the notes, and here you use them. The aim is to get used to the sizes that come up in orbital mechanics. A low orbit is a few hundred kilometres above the ground and takes an hour and a half. A geostationary orbit is \(42\,000\) km from the centre of the Earth and takes a day. A trip to another planet takes months, and a trip to the edge of the solar system takes decades. On the way you will work with the \(\mu\) of the Earth, the Moon, Mars, Venus and the Sun, and you will see how much the answers change from one body to the next.

There are eleven problems. Most are short. Problems 4, 10 and 11 are longer, and each one follows a mission from start to finish. The suggested times below add up to about \(170\) minutes, which leaves a few minutes to check your work in three hours.

Problem Topic Suggested time
1 Which \(\mu\)? The Earth and the Moon 8 min
2 An elliptic orbit and Kepler’s equation 15 min
3 The hyperbola of a passing asteroid 10 min
4 From a state vector to the elements, and back 30 min
5 The same Hohmann transfer at three bodies 10 min
6 Hohmann or bi-elliptic, to Neptune’s orbit 12 min
7 Moving a geostationary satellite 10 min
8 Turning the apse line 10 min
9 Where to burn 15 min
10 Patched conics, from the Earth to Venus 30 min
11 A ballistic test flight 20 min

The notes you need are The N-body Problem, The 2-body Problem, The Perifocal Frame, Orbital Elements, the six notes on orbital manoeuvres from The Impulsive Model to Escape, Patched Conics and Ballistic Trajectories.

How to work. Write down the formula you use before you put numbers into it, and say which note it comes from. Keep five or six significant figures in the working and give the answers to three or four, with units. Set your calculator to radians for Kepler’s equation, for mean motions and for any angle that multiplies a length or a time. Use degrees only to report an angle. All burns are impulsive and every body is a point mass. Some data are marked assumed. They are reasonable values chosen for the problem, not flown values.

Use the following constants in every problem.

Quantity Value
\(G\) \(6.6743\times10^{-20}\) km\(^3\)/(kg s\(^2\))
Earth \(\mu_\oplus=398\,600.4418\) km\(^3\)/s\(^2\), \(R_\oplus=6378.137\) km, \(M_\oplus=5.9722\times10^{24}\) kg
Moon \(\mu_{\rm Moon}=4902.8\) km\(^3\)/s\(^2\), \(R_{\rm Moon}=1737.4\) km, \(M_{\rm Moon}=7.342\times10^{22}\) kg, distance from the Earth \(D=384\,400\) km
Mars \(\mu_{\rm Mars}=42\,828.37\) km\(^3\)/s\(^2\), \(R_{\rm Mars}=3396.2\) km
Venus \(\mu_{\rm Venus}=324\,858.59\) km\(^3\)/s\(^2\), \(R_{\rm Venus}=6051.8\) km, orbit radius \(0.72333\) AU
Sun \(\mu_\odot=1.327\,124\,400\,18\times10^{11}\) km\(^3\)/s\(^2\)
Distances \(1\) AU \(=1.495\,978\,707\times10^{8}\) km, radius of Neptune’s orbit \(30.07\) AU
Geostationary orbit radius \(r_{\rm GEO}=42\,164\) km, period one sidereal day \(=86\,164.09\) s
Time one day \(=86\,400\) s, one year \(=365.25\) days

Treat every planetary orbit as a circle in the plane of the ecliptic.

Problem 1 — Which \(\mu\)? The Earth and the Moon

The Earth and the Moon are \(D=384\,400\) km apart. Take the Moon’s orbit as a circle.

  1. Find the distance of the centre of mass of the Earth and the Moon from the centre of the Earth. Is it inside the Earth or outside it, and by how much?
  2. The period of the Moon’s orbit depends on which \(\mu\) we use. Find the period, in days, with \(\mu=G(M_\oplus+M_{\rm Moon})\), and again with \(\mu=\mu_\oplus\). How many hours apart are the two answers? Which one is correct for the relative orbit of the Moon about the Earth?
  3. A geostationary satellite sits on the line from the Earth to the Moon, on the side facing the Moon. Find the accelerations that the Earth, the Moon and the Sun each give it, in m/s\(^2\). For the Sun take the distance as \(1\) AU.
  4. What disturbs the orbit of the satellite about the Earth is not the pull of a third body but the difference between its pull on the satellite and its pull on the Earth. For the Moon this difference is \(\mu_{\rm Moon}\bigl[1/(D-r_{\rm GEO})^2-1/D^2\bigr]\). For the Sun, with the satellite on the line to the Sun, it is close to \(2\mu_\odot r_{\rm GEO}/(1\ {\rm AU})^3\). Find both, and compare each with the Earth’s pull. Which body disturbs a geostationary orbit more?

Problem 2 — An elliptic orbit and Kepler’s equation

Before a mission leaves for the Moon, it spends some weeks raising its orbit about the Earth. Take one of these orbits to have a perigee altitude of \(200\) km and an apogee altitude of \(71\,000\) km (assumed).

  1. Find \(r_p\), \(r_a\), \(a\), \(e\), \(p\), the specific angular momentum \(h\), the specific energy \(\varepsilon\) and the period, in hours.
  2. Find the speeds at perigee and at apogee. What is their ratio?
  3. On its way out, the spacecraft crosses the radius of the geostationary orbit, \(r_{\rm GEO}=42\,164\) km. Find the true anomaly there, in degrees and in radians.
  4. Find the eccentric anomaly and the mean anomaly at that point, both in radians, and the time it takes to get there from perigee.
  5. Find the speed and the flight-path angle at that point.
  6. For how many hours of each orbit is the spacecraft closer to the Earth than \(r_{\rm GEO}\)? What fraction of the period is this?

Problem 3 — The hyperbola of a passing asteroid

On 13 April 2029 the asteroid Apophis will pass the Earth. Its closest approach is expected at about \(38\,012\) km from the centre of the Earth, and its speed relative to the Earth far away (its \(v_\infty\)) is about \(5.84\) km/s. Treat its path near the Earth as a hyperbola about the Earth alone.

  1. Find the semi-major axis \(|a|\) and the eccentricity of the hyperbola.
  2. Find the speed at closest approach. Published reports give the speed of the encounter as \(7.42\) km/s. Which speed do they mean?
  3. Find the angle through which the Earth turns the asteroid’s path.
  4. Find the aiming radius \(b\). Compare \(b\) and \(r_p\) with the radius of the geostationary orbit, and say what the comparison tells you.

Problem 4 — From a state vector to the elements, and back

A launch from Sriharikota puts a satellite on a geostationary transfer orbit. Some time later its tracking gives the position and velocity, in the geocentric equatorial frame,

\[ \mathbf r=(12\,806.3,\ -16\,065.0,\ 6104.1)\ \text{km},\qquad \mathbf v=(0.3344,\ 4.5392,\ -0.4312)\ \text{km/s}. \]

  1. Find \(r\), \(v\) and the radial velocity \(v_r\). Is the satellite moving towards the Earth or away from it?
  2. Find \(\mathbf h\) and the inclination \(i\).
  3. Find the node vector \(\mathbf N\) and the right ascension of the ascending node \(\Omega\). Say which quadrant test you use.
  4. Find the eccentricity vector, \(e\) and the argument of perigee \(\omega\), with its quadrant test.
  5. Find the true anomaly \(f\), with its quadrant test.
  6. Find \(a\), the altitudes of perigee and apogee, and the period.
  7. Now go back the other way. Find the position and velocity vectors of the satellite at its next apogee, in the geocentric equatorial frame. Use the perifocal unit vectors \(\hat{\mathbf p}\) and \(\hat{\mathbf q}\), expressed in the equatorial frame. Check that the two vectors you find are perpendicular.

Problem 5 — The same Hohmann transfer at three bodies

A spacecraft on a circular orbit \(200\) km above the surface is to be raised to a circular orbit \(1000\) km above the surface by a Hohmann transfer. Do this at the Earth, at the Moon and at Mars.

  1. For each body, find the two circular speeds, the two burns and the total, in m/s, and the time of the transfer, in minutes.
  2. Put the three results in a table. At which body is the raise cheapest, and at which does it take longest? Explain both in a sentence each.

Problem 6 — Hohmann or bi-elliptic, to Neptune’s orbit

A spacecraft is on the Earth’s orbit about the Sun, a circle of \(1\) AU. It is to reach a circular orbit at the distance of Neptune, \(30.07\) AU. Ignore the planets and use only the Sun’s gravity.

  1. Find the two burns, the total and the time of flight, in years, for a Hohmann transfer.
  2. Find the three burns, the total and the time of flight for a bi-elliptic transfer whose intermediate apoapsis is at \(60\) AU.
  3. Which transfer is cheaper, and by how much? Is the saving worth the time? Voyager 2 took about twelve years to reach Neptune. What did it do differently?

Problem 7 — Moving a geostationary satellite

ISRO sometimes moves a geostationary satellite to a new longitude. A satellite is to be moved \(6^\circ\) east, that is \(6^\circ\) ahead in the direction of its motion, and to end up on the geostationary orbit again. It does this with two burns, one to enter a phasing orbit and one to leave it at the same point.

  1. Should the phasing orbit be larger or smaller than the geostationary orbit? Why?
  2. If the move takes one revolution of the phasing orbit, find the period and the semi-major axis of the phasing orbit, the total \(\Delta v\) in m/s, and the time the move takes, in days.
  3. Repeat for a move that takes three revolutions.
  4. How far below the geostationary orbit does the satellite go in each case? Why might this matter to the operators of the other satellites in the geostationary belt?

Problem 8 — Turning the apse line

A satellite is on an orbit with perigee altitude \(600\) km and apogee altitude \(20\,000\) km. Its apse line is to be turned by \(\eta=40^\circ\), with the size and shape of the orbit unchanged.

  1. Find \(a\), \(e\) and \(p\).
  2. Find the cost of doing this with a single impulse. At what true anomalies on the initial orbit can the burn be made?
  3. At the first of these points, find the altitude, the speed and the flight-path angle. Check your answer to
    1. with \(\Delta v=2v\,|\sin\gamma|\).
  4. Find the cost of the two-burn route through the circular orbit at apogee. Which route is cheaper for \(\eta=40^\circ\)? For what angle \(\eta\) do the two routes cost the same?

Problem 9 — Where to burn

The same idea decides two very different burns. This problem puts them side by side.

  1. India’s Mars Orbiter Mission was captured into an orbit about Mars with periapsis altitude \(421.7\) km and apoapsis altitude \(76\,993.6\) km. Find \(a\), \(e\), the period in hours, and the speeds at periapsis and apoapsis. Suppose the plane of this orbit had to be turned by \(5^\circ\), with the apse line along the line of nodes so that either apsis could be used. Find the cost of the turn at periapsis and at apoapsis, in m/s. Why is the ratio of the two costs equal to \(r_a/r_p\)?
  2. Aditya-L1 left the Earth from an orbit with perigee altitude \(256\) km and apogee altitude \(121\,973\) km. Suppose a spacecraft on this orbit had to leave the Earth with \(v_\infty=1\) km/s. Find the burn needed at perigee and the burn needed at apogee. Compare both with the burn needed from a circular orbit at \(300\) km. If the spacecraft is at apogee, how long must it wait to make the cheaper burn?
  3. In one sentence each, say where a plane change should be made and where a burn that adds energy should be made, and why the two answers are opposite.

Problem 10 — Patched conics, from the Earth to Venus

ISRO’s Venus Orbiter Mission, Shukrayaan, is to orbit Venus on an elliptic orbit. Plan an ideal version of its journey. It leaves from a circular parking orbit \(300\) km above the Earth and travels to Venus on a Hohmann transfer about the Sun. At Venus one burn at periapsis captures it into an orbit with periapsis altitude \(500\) km and apoapsis altitude \(60\,000\) km (assumed). All orbits are in one plane.

  1. Find the semi-major axis of the transfer ellipse and the time of flight, in days.
  2. Find the speeds of the Earth and Venus about the Sun, the speeds on the transfer ellipse at departure and at arrival, and the hyperbolic excess speeds \(v_{\infty1}\) at the Earth and \(v_{\infty2}\) at Venus. In which direction, relative to the Earth’s motion, must the spacecraft leave the Earth’s sphere of influence?
  3. Find the angle by which Venus must lead or trail the Earth at departure. Find the synodic period, in days. If a launch window is missed, how long is the wait for the next one?
  4. Find the departure burn from the parking orbit and the characteristic energy \(C_3=v_{\infty1}^2\).
  5. Find the capture burn at Venus and the period of the capture orbit, in hours.
  6. Find the radius of Venus’s sphere of influence, \(r_{\rm SOI}=r_{\rm Venus}(\mu_{\rm Venus}/\mu_\odot)^{2/5}\). Is the capture orbit safely inside it?
  7. Find the total \(\Delta v\) of the two burns. How much more would the capture cost if the spacecraft went straight into a circular orbit at \(500\) km?

Problem 11 — A ballistic test flight

A test flight leaves the east coast of India for a target area in the Bay of Bengal and the Indian Ocean. Burnout is at an altitude of \(200\) km with a speed of \(5.2\) km/s. Take re-entry at the same altitude as burnout, so the free flight is symmetric, and measure the range along the surface as \(R_\oplus\psi\), where \(\psi\) is the free-flight range angle. Ignore the rotation of the Earth and the powered and re-entry parts of the flight.

  1. Find \(Q\). Find the largest free-flight range angle, the largest range in km, and the flight-path angle at burnout that gives it.
  2. The target is \(3000\) km away. Find \(\psi\) in radians and in degrees, and the two flight-path angles at burnout that reach it.
  3. For each of the two flights, find the semi-major axis, the eccentricity and the altitude of apogee. Why is \(a\) the same for both?
  4. For each flight, find the time of free flight, in minutes.
  5. Find the least burnout speed that could reach the target, and the flight-path angle it needs. How much margin does \(5.2\) km/s leave?